Jul 28, 2014 an economic and moral case for legalizing cocaine and heroin. A recent article by david luhnow in the wall street journal, saving mexico, contains a lot of good economic analysis of the market for illegal drugs, as well as a few statements that a completely economically literate. If the impact of economic stress on crime trends can be further understood, and even forecasted in the shortterm, then there is the potential to gain much through policy development and crime prevention action. But economics is different from these other social sciences, because of what economists study and how they study it. The presumed justification for the special legal treatment of drugs is that drug use causes substantial harm both to drug users and to society generally. In this sense, it has something in common with psychology, sociology, and political science. A few thoughts on the economics of drug trade might give us guidance. Drugrelated crime undoubtedly accounts for a large part of the external costs of illicit drug use. Stimulants, such as amphetamines, can delay sleep and elevate a persons mood, but high amounts can cause nervousness and anxiety in the user. Drug decriminalization and the price of illicit drugs.
Drugs, economics, and liberty foundation for economic. Ending the drug wars executive summary john collins, editor a. An economic analysis of a drugselling gangs finances steven d. The socio economics and class disparity of addiction. Drugs would interest economists as examples of demerit goods which can injure the health of users and impose costs on others. The economics of drug prohibition and drug legalization. Supporters of drug prohibition typically argue that drug use. These two relationships together form the principal hypothesis examining whether increases in substance prices will directly decrease the incidence of criminal violence. The economics of the illegal drug market kellogg insight. All else equal, it would be preferable to seize the same amount of drugs at the end of the supply chain, when the value of drugs is the highest.
The new economics of drug pricing could be radically different in the future and there is space for creative firms to define exactly what that means in. On the contrary, the presuniption from this quarter is that a free market in marijuana, cocaine. Political pressure for the lberahsation of drug laws has come from those who use drugs, and from these who are sympathetic to the plight of drug users. Economics and the legalisation of drugs chris wilkiins and fraik scrimgeour r i ftie debate over the future cof drug control policy has largely been political and ideological. I believe this practice of developing me too drugs is unethical because the costs outweigh the benefits. What results is a fairly interesting and innovative book that mixes both journalistic style interviewing and reporting with business and economic principles though these. The highest opium content was observed in the province of badakhshan slightly more than 16% on average. Planet money do economists theories about drugs hold up in the real world. The economic patterns of illicit drug trafficking follow the same principles of any illegal good or service with a reasonable real demand.
Levittandsudhiralladivenkatesh we use a unique data set detailing the nancial activities of a drugselling street gang to analyze gang economics. An economic and moral case for legalizing cocaine and heroin. Making an economic case for legalizing drugs cato institute. Drugs trafficking needs to press because give effect big losses either directly or indirectly. Theres no mystery why people use mindaltering drugs. Earlier versions of the essays which make up the book s section on justice and efficiency originally appeared as blackstone and bentham, 19 j. How to run a drug cartel, by tom wainwright, is a book that examines the modern drug business both illegal and legal in terms of actual business principles. For full access to this pdf, sign in to an existing account, or purchase an annual subscription. Pitt university of minnesota, minneapolis, mn 55455, usa received december 1981, revised version received september 1983. Lawlessness and economics can be regarded as a sub. The positive association between substance use and violence is well documented, as is the negative relationship between the quantity of alcohol or drugs consumed and their prices. Sudhir alladi venkatesh, an economic analysis of a drugselling gangs finances, the quarterly journal of economics, volume 115, issue 3.
Jul 06, 2015 persico, a professor of managerial economics and decision sciences at the kellogg school, developed a new model of the drug market that accounts for the fact that buyers do not know a drugs purity before purchasing it, as well as the fact that they cannot contest sales of impure drugs. Doing economics makes students aware of what experienced researchers know implicitly. Previously she worked at the interamerican development bank. However, there is not nearly as much consensus as to what is the correct public response to narcotics use and sales. Chapter 2 macroeconomic impact of the drug economy and. On average, earnings in the gang are somewhat above the legitimate labor market alternative. Stop aerial spraying of drug crops with toxic pesticides. After all, there is nothing special about the production.
Ensure easy access to clean needles, oral drugs such as methadone to reduce injecting and naloxene, the antidote to overdoses. Persico, a professor of managerial economics and decision sciences at the kellogg school, developed a new model of the drug market that accounts for the fact that buyers do not know a drugs purity before purchasing it, as well as the fact that they cannot contest sales of. Kate waldock is a doctoral candidate in economics at the stern school of business at new york university. Health economists would have a role in helping to evaluate alternative therapies but general economic considerations would. Countries should work toward developing policies and laws that decriminalize injection and other use of drugs and, thereby, reduce incarceration. Pdf the effects of decriminalization of drug use in portugal. For example, godfrey et al 2002 estimated that around 88% of the economic and social costs of class a drug use in england and wales in 2000 was attributable to crime and policing costs. Prohibiting a good does not eliminate the market for. Drugs, economics, and liberty 1998 no one disputes that narcotics do harm to people. Drug consumption, crime and other drug related externalities embrace at least three areas of economics. Pdf economic aspects of drugs trading in yogyakarta.
Jan 08, 2016 the new economics of drug pricing could be radically different in the future and there is space for creative firms to define exactly what that means in our modern connected world, just as. This briefing paper surveys the relative handful of studies that have been able to evaluate the workings of drug markets. Unaccounted costs, lost lives, missed opportunities introduction the war on drugs is an expensive proposition. Thus, drug prohibition creates a black market in drugs rather than eliminating drugs. Political economy of illegal drugs routledge studies in. Under good practice recommendations concerning decriminalization, the who recommends that for people who use or inject drugs. He has authored seven books and is a frequent guest on national radio shows. The disagreement is on the form of the connection and the sign of the correlation. List of books and articles about legalization of drugs. The economics of the war on illegal drug production and. It maintains that there are no market failures which could justify a banning of these substances, and that, as in the earlier historical case of prohibition of alcohol, our present drug policy has increased crime, decreased respect for legitimate law, and created great. The direct costs of policing and interdiction of drug supply in some countries include not just ordinary policing but extensive military and paramilitary operations. May 20, 2010 a few thoughts on the economics of drug trade might give us guidance.
Economicswith andwithout the law princeton university. The prohibition of drugs is assumed necessary to reduce the consumption of drugs and thereby reduce the ills caused by drug consumption. Worlds opium production in metric tons 2 unodc 2004. A primary reason to focus on the impact of the policy change on the price of drugs is the presumed e ect of prices on use and consumption. The economics of the war on illegal drug production and tra. Physiological effects of drug abuse vary by the type of drug. Depressants, by contrast, impair mental and physical functions, and slow neural activity in the brain. Furthermore, it is crucial for policymakers to understand if there exists a causal relationship between drug decriminalization and. Even though prohibition does not eliminate drugs, it is likely to. Northholland smuggling and the black market for foreign exchange mark m. An economic analysis of alcohol, drugs, and violent crime.
A refreshing look at economics with topics ranging from sex, drugs, arms and music to energy, movies and farming, the internet and aids, diane coyle plunges herself and the reader into some of the world s most contentious political and social issues. One of the main arguments for legalizing drugs is that people should be free to consume whatever they want, even if it is harmful to them, as long as others are not affected. Lets start by acknowledging that there is no question whatsoever that narcotic use and sales in our country can be virtually eliminated. This paper argues the case for the legalization of addictive drugs such as marijuana, cocaine, and heroin. The economics of the illicit drug market in the united states have been a source of much speculation and misinformation. Thats not only true of cocaine, heroin, and marijuana. An introduction to the issues econ omic e valu atio n offe rs an op port unit y to be mo re effi cien t with t he res ourc es ava ilab le for d rug p olic y. A former crack kingpin on the economics of illegal drugs npr. This handy reference text provides undergraduate students with a practical introduction to research methodology. The prohibition of drugs is assumed necessary to reduce the consumption of drugs and thereby. Economic analysis of a drugselling gangs finances the.
Bnn national narcotics agency reported that the loss of national economic and social aspects as a. The beckley foundation drug policy programme is a member of the international drug policy consortium idpc. Economics there is nothing in the tenets of value free eco nomics that would preclude the legalization of drugs. Health economists would have a role in helping to evaluate alternative therapies but general economic considerations would not loom large in discussions of drug issues. First, economics is a social science, so it seeks to explain something about society. Contents an explanatory note vii in which the origins of this book are clari. One point on which almost everyone interested in drug prohibition agrees is the existence of a connection between drugs and violent crime. This large and varied body of research has built upon pioneering ideas of coase 1937, 1960, 1988, north. However, opposers of drug legalization believe that the government has the right and responsibility to prohibit drug use. Studies 6 large seizures of substances are typically made at points in the supply chain where the value of drugs is lowerat or near the source. In this paper we shed further light on the impact of drug decriminalization on the illicit drug market by studying its impact on the price of illicit drugs. Medical experts call for global drug decriminalisation.
1150 773 553 619 821 556 847 1055 216 667 1317 959 396 756 531 1459 366 827 230 1037 569 155 1531 1390 350 1164 609 1031 1234 849 287 1152 196 377 519 577 559 765 96 948